If you want you online forum to attract a lot of traffic and a lot of comments… MAKE IT CONCRETE the below issues to drive more traffic to online forums
Our four largest consultations have been, in order: (1) a proposal to remove a heavy rail line; (2) a plan to allow multi-storey development within a residential suburb; (3) a plan to change bus routes and frequencies; and (4) a proposal to redevelop a heritage lighthouse.
Our four smallest consultations have been: (1) A shire wide vision document; (2) a master plan for a new suburb with no existing community; (3) a tree preservation policy; and (4) an annual management plan.
The difference between the two lists is obvious. The large consultations have all been concrete and easily understood issues that the community hand a strong opinion about and could get their proverbial teeth into. All four had elements of “threat” to an existing community position. Three of the four spoke to a much broader issue of “place”, i.e. “How do I feel about my city/suburb/town?” and “What kind of place do I want this to be in the future?” BUT, crucially, they did so through the lens of a single definable, concrete, project.
The smaller consultations were (a) high order and necessarily fairly non-confronting in nature – the projects coming out of the vision would likely generate a lot more feedback; (b) targeted to a very small audience; (c) non-controversial; and (d) impenetrable.
This does not mean that the smaller consultations were necessarily unsuccessful – success is measured against the objectives of the consultation. I’m not interested in success or otherwise in this context. What I interested in is what lessons can we learn from the larger consultations that can be applied to the smaller consultations if “traffic” and “comments” is a desirable outcome.
And rather than over complicating things, I think there is really only one lesson that matters…
MAKE THE ISSUE CONCRETE – if necessary pull projects out of management plans and similar documents to illustrate the “real” impacts of the plan/policy/programme. Your community needs to connect to the issue viscerally. It does not understand or want to read bureau speak. It is worth looking at the headlines in a tabloid newspaper and re-imagining your questions as tabloid headlines. Think about real projects and real impacts, rather than conceptual principles and policy frameworks.
Photo Credits: Cuba Gallery
Thanks for getting all the way to bottom! Subscribe to our monthly digest newsletter if you’d like to be kept up to date about community engagement practice globally. Take a look at our two product websites: EngagementHQ if you need a complete online engagement solution, and BudgetAllocator if you need a participatory budgeting solution. Or get in touch if you have a story idea you think is worth sharing.